Case Review: CL Financial’s Voided Proman Sale & The Newsday Winding-Up — Corporate Insolvency Law in Trinidad & Tobago
Reviewing landmark Trinidad High Court corporate rulings reported by the Trinidad Guardian: the voiding of CL Financial’s CLICO energy asset sale to Proman and the court-approved winding-up of Daily News Ltd (Newsday).
Trinidad and Tobago’s High Court has produced some of the Caribbean’s most sophisticated commercial and insolvency jurisprudence. From the multi-billion-dollar fallout of the CL Financial (CLF) / CLICO collapse to the court-supervised liquidation of major media companies like Daily News Limited (publisher of the Trinidad and Tobago Newsday), recent judgments illustrate how the Companies Act (Chap. 81:01) polices executive overreach, fiduciary breaches, and corporate insolvency.
Below, we review three major corporate rulings covered by the Trinidad and Tobago Guardian and explain what they mean for company directors, shareholders, and creditors.
- Trinidad & Tobago Guardian: High Court voids CL Financial’s decision to sell Clico energy assets to Proman
- Trinidad & Tobago Guardian: CIB liquidator loses lawsuit against top trio
- Trinidad & Tobago Guardian: Newsday wind-up approved by High Court
1. Voiding the CL Financial / Proman Energy Sale: Oppression & Fiduciary Breach
In January 2009, the conglomerate CL Financial Limited (CLF) and its insurance flagship CLICO sought an emergency multi-billion-dollar bailout from the Government of Trinidad and Tobago, signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) to pledge assets as security. Just days after signing the MOU—and without consulting the CLICO board or the Central Bank—former CLF executive chairman Lawrence Duprey executed a Purchase and Sale Agreement transferring CLF’s 51% majority stake in CLICO Energy Company Limited (holding lucrative methanol and petrochemical assets) to Proman Holding (Barbados) Limited for roughly US$46.5 million.
As reported by the Trinidad Guardian, High Court Justice Davindra Rampersad set aside and voided the sale in a sweeping judgment:
- Oppression Remedy & Fiduciary Duty (Companies Act, Section 99 & Section 242): The court ruled that Duprey acted oppressively and in breach of his fiduciary duty to act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the company.
- Undervaluation & Knowing Receipt: The High Court found the energy shares were sold at a substantial undervalue while the group was in acute financial distress, ordering Proman to return the shares and account for over US$168 million in accumulated dividends (subject to reimbursement of the original purchase price).
2. Limits on Director Liability: The CIB Liquidator Lawsuit
While courts will strike down self-dealing or oppressive asset transfers, liquidators bringing negligence or breach-of-duty claims against former executives must still satisfy strict evidentiary and limitation rules. In a separate High Court commercial ruling reported by the Trinidad Guardian, the Deposit Insurance Corporation (acting as liquidator of Clico Investment Bank [CIB]) lost a multi-million-dollar claim against three former senior figures.
The ruling underscored that under the Companies Act (Chap. 81:01), liquidators cannot rely on broad, generalized allegations of corporate collapse; they must prove specific, pleaded breaches of duty tied causally to identifiable transactions, and bring those claims within statutory limitation periods under the Limitation of Certain Actions Act.
3. Court-Supervised Winding-Up: The Daily News Limited (Newsday) Liquidation
In another major corporate milestone reported by the Trinidad Guardian, High Court Justice Marissa Robertson approved a winding-up petition for Daily News Limited, the parent company of the Trinidad and Tobago Newsday, appointing insolvency practitioner Maria Daniel as liquidator.
Under Part VI of the Companies Act (Chap. 81:01) and the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, once a High Court winding-up order is granted:
- Automatic Stay of Proceedings: All individual creditor lawsuits and executions against the company’s assets are stayed; creditors must submit formal proofs of debt to the court-appointed liquidator.
- Cessation of Directors’ Powers: The board of directors is displaced, and the liquidator assumes full statutory control to preserve assets, evaluate employee severance priorities, and sell or realize company property for the benefit of secured and unsecured creditors.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Trinidad High Court void CL Financial’s sale of CLICO Energy to Proman?
Justice Davindra Rampersad ruled that former executive chairman Lawrence Duprey acted oppressively and breached his fiduciary duties under the Companies Act by selling CLICO Energy’s shares at an undervalue without proper board authority just days after signing the 2009 state bailout MOU.
What happens when the Trinidad High Court approves a company winding-up order?
Under the Companies Act (Chap. 81:01), a court-appointed liquidator takes control of all company assets, the powers of the board of directors cease, and a statutory stay blocks individual creditor lawsuits so claims can be settled according to statutory priority.
Join the discussion on our Community Forum Thread.
Comments